roach or carp poll u choose

[roachman]

roach or carp u choose
what do u think
i think silver fish because they give a great fight when caught correctly and they are much more buitiful than a carp
but i would love to hear you sugestions!!!!!!!!
please give your reason y

[fishypaul]

caught on the correct tackle i think i would prefer a roach any time

[roachman]

tanx for your answer i agree totaly

[Banana Steve]

To catch a 2lb roach was a dream i held for many years and when i finnaly caught one i was so overjoyed, i have caught carp to 52lb, and to be very honest the roach will always be the best fish i have ever caught. fishing with light tackle in dead of winter on the river, i only had three bites that day in a match and third bite was the roach, to see the silver flanks come through the water, well my heart pounding my legs shaking. A experience that i will never forget.

[roachman]

awsome catch i caught 1 aswel its amazing tahnx for the reply